目前共有18篇帖子。 字體大小:較小 - 100% (默認)▼  內容轉換:不轉換▼
 
點擊 回復
264 17
【Weekly Topic 20260125】The Classroom Debate — Online vs. In-Person Learning
副總編 二十三級
1樓 發表于:2026-1-25 21:58

Introduction:

Think back to your student days. Remember the rush to get to a physical classroom, the chats with classmates before the bell, and the direct gaze of a teacher. Now, think of today. Many of us have experienced learning from behind a screen—in our pajamas, perhaps with a cat walking across the keyboard. Both modes have become a significant part of our lives. This week, let's compare them. Was one method fundamentally better for you, or did each serve a different purpose? Share your experiences, your struggles, and your unexpected wins from both sides of the screen.


Sub-questions:

1. The First Snapshots: Describe one very clear, specific advantage of online learning. Then, describe one very clear, specific advantage of in-person learning. (e.g., "Online: I could replay the lecture recording." / "In-person: I could easily form a study group after class.")

2. Personal Experience: Which learning environment generally worked better for you and your personality? Share a short story or a key observation that explains why. Was it about focus, interaction, convenience, or something else?

3. The Hybrid Future: If you were to design the perfect learning system for a future student, what is the one core element you would take from online learning and the one core element you would take from in-person learning to include? Why are these two elements so important?

4. Off-topic Corner: What was the most memorable or funniest thing a teacher or instructor ever did during a lesson (online or offline)?


A note from your host:

There are no right or wrong answers here—just honest perspectives. Your experience, whether as a recent student or a lifelong learner, is valuable. Let's understand this modern shift in education together. I'm looking forward to reading your stories and insights.


副總編 二十三級
2樓 發表于:2026-1-25 22:11

Tips


1.Don't forget to set zoom-in (medium - 125%) to get a bigger font size so that you can read easier. (only on PC)


2.Expression Bag: https://zh.purasbar.com/post.php?t=35386


3.Talk Toolkit: https://zh.purasbar.com/post.php?t=35383

 
下位魔導師 十八級
3樓 發表于:2026-1-26 16:09
Welp, I prefer Online Learning, but objectively its efficiency is obviously less than the efficiency of In-Person Learning
 
啊啊是谁都对:Welp, I understand where you're coming from, but I'd like to challenge the efficiency assumption. Students can usually change the video's speed when on online learning. However, teachers will use the same speed in traditional learning. So with the help of online learning, students can learn the same thing with less time.
  2026-1-26 19:50 回復
下位魔導師 十八級
4樓 發表于:2026-1-27 12:58
The First Snapshots: Describe one very clear, specific advantage of online learning. Then, describe one very clear, specific advantage of in-person learning.

One specific advantage of online learning: People can drag the progress bar while learning. That means we can look back to previous knowledge at any time

One specific advantage of In-Person Learning: Students have to concentrate on learning. We cannot use smartphones in the classroom. This boosts efficiency and reduces distractions

 
啊啊是谁都对:I think so. Some knowledge is quite hard to understand for the first time. In classrooms, it's quite hard to control learning process.
  2026-1-31 23:22 回復
啊啊是谁都对:And for specific advantage of In-Person Learning, that's a fair. Discipline is quite of importance. As long as thye're for boosting efficiency.
  2026-1-31 23:27 回復
下位魔導師 十八級
5樓 發表于:2026-1-27 13:06
Personal Experience: Which learning environment generally worked better for you and your personality? Share a short story or a key observation that explains why. Was it about focus, interaction, convenience, or something else?


I think online learning is more suitable for me. Because I can take notes at any time and I don't have to hurry up. Or I can just make snapshots of the videos

 
啊啊是谁都对:I also love online learning!
  2026-1-31 23:29 回復
下位魔導師 十八級
6樓 發表于:2026-1-27 13:17
The Hybrid Future: If you were to design the perfect learning system for a future student, what is the one core element you would take from online learning and the one core element you would take from in-person learning to include? Why are these two elements so important?


I think I would still use classrooms to make students concentrate. But I will also make videos of the lessons and give students so that they can review the lesson after class

 
啊啊是谁都对:Hope these students can enjoy comfortable tables and chairs.
  2026-1-29 21:16 回復
啊啊是谁都对:Then in the classrooms, are students listening to teachers or watching videos?
  2026-1-31 23:30 回復
初級魔法師 五級
7樓 發表于:2026-1-30 13:50

2. Personal Experience: Which learning environment generally worked better for you and your personality? Share a short story or a key observation that explains why. Was it about focus, interaction, convenience, or something else?


It's hard to say... I can study better with online classes because I can learn whatever I want and get answers to my questions at any time. But I may feel lonely if I only sit behind my computer without any classmate around.  Though I know they are exactly there behind a screen,  I find it hard to take them as real people. 

Having others around not only reduces my loneliness but also improves my learning efficiency,  since I tend to entertain myself when alone. 

 
啊啊是谁都对:How about some Internet community that have in-person activities?
  2026-1-30 16:53 回復
啊啊是谁都对:By the way, long time no see! Are you in winter vacation now?
  2026-1-30 20:30 回復
初級魔法師 五級
8樓 發表于:2026-1-30 13:59
3. The Hybrid Future: If you were to design the perfect learning system for a future student, what is the one core element you would take from online learning and the one core element you would take from in-person learning to include? Why are these two elements so important?


The classroom and classmates from in-person learning.  Then,  they can learn whatever they are into by teleporting to specific classrooms,  and have lessons that are suitable for their learning levels,  just like online learning.  And they can bring smart phones.

 
啊啊是谁都对:I wonder if they can use laptops.
  2026-1-31 23:21 回復
lizhenxuan:回复 @啊啊是谁都对:Yes,  it is even better. 
  2026-2-7 23:12 回復

回復帖子

內容:
用戶名: 您目前是匿名發表
驗證碼:
(快捷鍵:Ctrl+Enter)
 

本帖信息

點擊數:264 回複數:17
評論數: ?
作者:啊啊是谁都对
最後回復:lizhenxuan
最後回復時間:2026-2-7 23:12
精品區:Discuss
 
©2010-2026 Purasbar Ver2.0
除非另有聲明,本站採用創用CC姓名標示-相同方式分享 3.0 Unported許可協議進行許可。