設置 | 登錄 | 註冊

目前共有2篇帖子。

Question: Which of these sentences is correct?

1樓 圆环之理 2024-9-26 14:52
The original link: https://forum.thefreedictionary.com/postst265848_of-whom.aspx


Which are correct:

1) I had a chance to talk to Paul Newman, meeting whom was always delightful.
2) I talked to an actor meeting whom was always delightful.

3) I had a chance to talk to Paul Newman, the meeting of whom was always delightful.
4) I talked to an actor the meeting of whom was always delightful.

Gratefully,
Navi

2樓 圆环之理 2024-9-26 14:52
As far as I know, these sentences can be written as:

"I had a chance to talk to Paul Newman, whose meetings were always delightful."

Whose is a possessive relative pronoun and "whose meetings were always delightful" is a relative clause modifying Paul Newman.


I cannot relate to any of the syntaxes that I know of for all four sentences, even though "I had a chance to talk to Paul Newman, the meeting of whom was always delightful" looks familiar.

Maybe Audiendus, Dragonspeaker, and Thar can shed some light on this.

I look forward to their replies.

Thanks
brp7

內容轉換:

回覆帖子
內容:
用戶名: 您目前是匿名發表。
驗證碼:
看不清?換一張
©2010-2025 Purasbar Ver3.0 [手機版] [桌面版]
除非另有聲明,本站採用知識共享署名-相同方式共享 3.0 Unported許可協議進行許可。